Effective Ways to Increase SMS Engagement and Minimize Opt-Outs

SMS marketing is a must-have for your business’s toolbox. You’re tapping into one of the most direct and engaging communication channels available today. Studies show that SMS messages boast a staggering 98% open rate, often within minutes of receipt.

However, with great power comes great responsibility. Mishandle your SMS campaigns, and you risk alienating your audience, driving them to opt out faster than you can say “unsubscribe.”

That’s obviously not an outcome you want, so how can you avoid it? How can you tap into what this tool offers and boost SMS engagement, while still respecting your audience and keeping them firmly on your side?

This guide will help you walk that fine line—maximizing SMS engagement while minimizing opt-outs. Let’s dive into strategies that ensure your SMS efforts deliver value and strengthen customer relationships.

Why SMS Engagement Matters

SMS isn’t just another marketing channel. When done right, texting is a high-touchpoint way to connect with customers where they’re already active and to do so while getting around all the noise from other channels. Done right, it can do wonders for your business.

SMS Drives Revenue and Loyalty

Think of SMS as a direct route to customer engagement. Personalized, timely texts can:

• Increase sales: Exclusive deals or limited-time offers create urgency and drive purchases. And because you’re able to get your message to their phone, you don’t have to worry about the constraints that limit other channels, like social media, or even email marketing.
• Boost loyalty: Consistent, value-driven communication reminds customers why they chose you. They start looking for your texts with anticipation. When a message notification flashes on the screen, they’re interested and intrigued, not annoyed.
• Enhance customer satisfaction: Real-time updates—like order confirmations or delivery alerts—make life easier for your audience. It’s a way of investing in the customer experience that delivers value above and beyond what they derive from your product or service, and it strengthens the bond between them and your brand considerably.

Of course, you can only enjoy those benefits if you do things right. Get them wrong, and you’ll have customers unsubscribing left and right. You’ll suffer from reduced loyalty, decreased customer satisfaction, and fewer sales. All that can erode your market position pretty quickly.

The Cost of Losing Subscribers

Every opt-out isn’t just one less subscriber—it’s a missed opportunity for connection and a damaged relationship. Worse, frequent opt-outs signal that your approach might be missing the mark, impacting your brand reputation and overall campaign success.

If you’re seeing a rising number of opt-outs, it’s worth drilling down into your SMS campaigns to find out what’s going wrong and figure out what you can do to fix things. Below, we’ll talk about some of the most common things to go wrong in SMS marketing.

Why Customers Opt Out

• Message Overload
• Irrelevant Content
• Poor Timing

To keep your audience engaged, you’ve got to understand why they might leave. Here are the most common reasons—and how to address them.

1. Message Overload

Customers don’t want their phones blowing up with endless promotions. Bombard them, and they’ll opt out faster than you can blink. This is the single most common reason that someone opts out of communication with a brand, and that applies beyond the world of SMS. If you’re seeing high unsubscribe numbers from your email marketing or you’re having trouble on social media, chances are good that you’re causing message overload.

Fix: Limit your sends to 2–4 messages per month unless your audience explicitly opts into higher-frequency campaigns. Note that the closer those messages are together, the more likely your recipient will feel overloaded. Try to keep your messages pretty far apart unless they’re directly related to one another.

2. Irrelevant Content

If your messages don’t align with what your audience values, they’ll lose interest. They subscribed for a reason. If you’re not delivering content that ties in with that reason, then what’s the point of being a subscriber? In most cases, your audience is made up of people connected to your business for different reasons.

It’s your job to figure out what those reasons are and then serve up relevant information. Sure, you can occasionally test the waters with adjacent messages but stray too far from their primary reason for connecting with your brand in the first place, and you’ll lose them.

Fix: Segment your audience based on behavior, location, or preferences to deliver content that resonates. Evolve your messaging to each customer over time based on their interactions and history with your brand. In other words, start slow and be relevant. As the relationship matures, you can start expanding your messaging but doing that too soon can be damaging.

3. Poor Timing

Sending texts at odd hours (hello, 3 a.m. flash sale) can disrupt your customer’s day—and your relationship with them. The worst times to message someone are early in the morning, late at night, during rush hour, on holidays, and during wind-down or family time in the evening. These are all periods where your messages will come through as disruptive (not in a good way) and you stand a good chance of having people opt out.

Fix: Know your audience’s time zones and typical behavior patterns to time your messages effectively. Yes, this means you’ll need to track your audience’s geographic location and then customize your SMS strategy to avoid disruptive times. Doing so will help you keep more subscribers and also help you avoid developing a negative reputation.

There you have them – three of the most common reasons people unsubscribe from SMS campaigns. The golden rule is really this: be relevant and respectful. If you can do that, your audience will reward you.

Top Strategies to Increase SMS Engagement

• Personalize Your Messages
• Optimize Timing and Frequency
• Deliver Value with Every Text
• Use Interactive Elements
• Create a Sense of Urgency

Now that we’ve talked a bit about why your audience might be opting out, it’s time to discuss enhancing SMS customer engagement. The right steps can amplify your efforts, cement loyalty, and yield rich rewards.

1. Personalize Your Messages

A little personalization goes a long way. Instead of blasting generic offers, use customer data to tailor your texts.

• Greet customers by name.
• Reference past purchases or interactions.
• Suggest relevant products based on their browsing habits.

Personalized SMS campaigns can lead to a 14% higher click-through rate compared to non-personalized ones. And remember that it’s not just about bumping up your CTR. Real engagement comes from real relationships. It’s your job to build those. The rest will come in its own time.

2. Optimize Timing and Frequency

Timing is everything. Too often, and you’ll overwhelm your audience. Too infrequent, and they might forget about you.

Pro tip: Experiment with A/B testing to find the sweet spot.

• Consider time-sensitive sends like lunchtime promotions or evening event reminders.

Work with both your audience’s preferences and your offerings. If you’re running a local buffet restaurant, then mid-morning texts are great. If you’re a national shoe brand, you’ll need to segment your audience, send times, and more to get your message in front of your audience members at the right time for them (after a morning run, Sunday afternoon after their long run, etc.).

3. Deliver Value with Every Text

Your audience’s time is precious. No one likes having their time wasted. It’s disrespectful, and your audience won’t stick around if they feel like you don’t truly care. Make sure every message serves a purpose:

• Offer exclusive deals they won’t find elsewhere.
• Provide early access to sales or new products.
• Share useful updates, like shipping notifications or appointment reminders.
• Communicate important information, like emergency notifications about outages or other issues.

Ultimately, remember that the point here is to deliver value to your customers, not to your business. You’re not the hero of the story. Your customers are.

4. Use Interactive Elements

Want to make SMS a two-way street? Incorporate polls, surveys, or feedback requests to invite interaction. Get people involved in the conversation! Not only will this build engagement and help strengthen your relationship, but you’ll also get access to important information that you can then use to customize future texts.

Example: “What flavor should we launch next? Reply A for Mango, B for Raspberry!”

Interactive campaigns keep your brand top of mind while gathering valuable customer insights. They also help make your audience members feel like they’re part of something, and we all like to feel involved with and connected to the brands we support.

5. Create a Sense of Urgency

Urgency can be a powerful motivator. Try limited-time offers or countdowns to encourage immediate action. But don’t be disingenuous. Those “only 3 left in stock!” messages? They’re dishonest if you actually have plenty of product on hand. No one wants to be manipulated. Create a sense of urgency through genuine initiatives and actions and your audience will be much happier (and more engaged!).

Proven Ways to Minimize SMS Opt-Out Rates and Improve SMS Customer Engagement

• Set Clear Expectations at Opt-In
• Segment Your Audience
• Offer Preference Controls
• Honor Opt-Outs Immediately

1. Set Clear Expectations at Opt-In

Transparency builds trust. When customers sign up, tell them what to expect:

• How often you’ll text.
• The type of content you’ll send.

This simple step reduces surprises—and opt-outs.

2. Segment Your Audience

One-size-fits-all messaging doesn’t cut it. Segmentation helps you deliver the right message to the right person.

Examples: New customers might appreciate welcome offers, while repeat buyers might prefer loyalty rewards.

3. Offer Preference Controls

Give customers control over their SMS experience. Allow them to adjust:

• Frequency of messages.
• Types of messages (e.g., promotions vs. updates).

4. Honor Opt-Outs Immediately

If someone wants to unsubscribe, make it quick and painless. Failure to respect opt-outs can damage your brand’s reputation—and even lead to legal issues.

Measuring and Optimizing SMS Engagement

Finally, we need to talk about measurement and tracking so that you can fine-tune your campaigns. Like the strategies we discussed above, these will help you improve SMS customer engagement.

Track Key Metrics

If you don’t measure and monitor, you’ll never know what you’re doing wrong (or right). To know what’s working, monitor these essential metrics:

• Click-through rates (CTR): How many people clicked your link?
• Response rates: Are customers replying to interactive texts?
• Opt-out rates: Is your unsubscribe rate staying low?

Test and Iterate

A/B testing is your best friend when it comes to SMS engagement. Experiment with different variables, such as:

• Message length.
• Call-to-action phrasing.
• Sending times.

However, don’t get bogged down in A/B testing every little thing. It’s all too easy to go down the rabbit hole here and then realize that you’ve wasted an incredible amount of time and money testing things that don’t ultimately matter.

Boost Engagement with SMS Done Right

SMS marketing is powerful, but it demands respect for your audience’s time and preferences. By personalizing your messages, delivering value, and honoring your customers’ trust, you’ll not only increase engagement but also build long-lasting loyalty.

Ready to elevate your SMS campaigns? Explore DialMyCalls to access tools that make SMS marketing seamless and effective. From emergency notifications to promotional texts, we’ve got everything you need to succeed.

• Previous Article